Best Pizza Restaurants in New Haven

Real videos of Pizza Restaurants in New Haven — 12 places, filmed by creators on the ground.

Ranked venues

Sally's Apizza
View Venue
$$CasualTraditionalInvitingThin-crust pizzaCoal-firedHigh-quality ingredients
About the venue
Sally's Apizza in New Haven is renowned for its classic thin-crust pizza with a rich tomato sauce and toppings ranging from fresh mozzarella to artisanal meats. Established during the 1930s, it has garnered a loyal following for its high-quality ingredients and traditional pizza-making methods. The pizzeria maintains a casual and welcoming atmosphere, often filled with families and groups enjoying a slice. The restaurant is also known for its pies baked in a coal-fired oven, enhancing the flavors.
What the videos show
The video showcases a person picking up slices of a large pizza with toppings of sausage and onions. The camera focuses on the pizza and the actions of lifting the slices, with varying amounts of cheese visible on each slice.
237 Wooster St
@Mamaj
@adventureswithchass
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
View Venue
$$HistoricBusyTraditionalCoal-fired pizzaWhite clamFamily recipes
About the venue
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, established in 1925 and located on Commerce Dr in Murray, Connecticut, is renowned for its coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas. The pizzeria is famous for its signature white clam pizza, a recipe that has gained loyal patrons over generations. The rustic interior is always buzzing with locals and pizza aficionados eager to experience the time-honored recipes. Diners can also enjoy classic Italian dishes alongside their pizzas, making it a well-rounded dining destination.
What the videos show
The video begins with a close-up of two pizzas in a cardboard box, one with chicken and herbs and the other a cheese pizza. The camera then pans up to reveal the exterior of Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana at night, seen through a car window.
238 Commerce Dr
@thestacetaste
@MealSeeker
One 6 Three
View Venue
$DiverseElegantCasualInternational menuArtisanal cocktailsChanging specials
About the venue
One 6 Three, located in New Haven, Connecticut, is known for its diverse and international menu in a relaxed yet elegant setting since its opening. The restaurant offers a mix of global cuisines along with a selection of artisanal cocktails and wines. Its focus on creative dishes leads to ever-changing specials, attracting food lovers looking for unique dining experiences. The combination of attentive service and a comfortable ambiance makes it a popular spot for both dinner and brunch.
What the videos show
The video showcases the exterior and interior of One Three Pizza Joint, highlighting the pizza-making process and various dishes like pepperoni pizza, tater tots, and a chicken parmesan pizza.
163 Foster St
@adventureswithchass
Modern Apizza
View Venue
$$ClassicCasualBustlingCoal-fired pizzaWhite clamLong wait
About the venue
Modern Apizza, a New Haven staple since 1934, is renowned for its coal-fired pizza cooked in a brick oven that gives it a distinct crispy crust. Located on State Street, this pizzeria offers a variety of toppings, including their famous white clam pizza—made with chopped clams, garlic, and mozzarella. The restaurant's no-nonsense decor focuses on the pizza experience rather than frills, attracting both locals and pizza tourists. The wait for a table can get long during peak hours, so plan accordingly.
What the videos show
The video begins with a close-up of a pizza topped with eggplant slices, then pans up to reveal a neon Budweiser sign and a menu board listing various food items and drinks. It concludes with a blurry shot of a woman smiling.
874 State St
@SprinkleMyDonut
@jkoos715
Bar
View Venue
$$LivelyCasualArtisanalCraft beersWood-fired pizzaLive music
About the venue
Bar in New Haven presents a lively atmosphere perfect for gatherings, featuring a focused selection of craft beers and cocktails. Known for its artisanal pizzas cooked in a wood-fired oven, the bar also serves a varied menu of shareable plates. With regular live music events and a spacious patio area, it has quickly become a favorite hangout spot for university students and local residents. The casual vibe and creative menu set it apart from other nightlife offerings in the area.
What the videos show
The video captures a static shot of two pizzas placed on a table with a wooden board in the foreground. There are no people visible, and the scene shows minor adjustments in the background, possibly due to patrons settling into their seats.
254 Crown St
@nomandmore
@LittyEats
Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana
View Venue
$CasualAuthenticCozyWood-fired pizzaNeapolitan styleHouse-made desserts
About the venue
Zeneli Pizzeria, located in New Haven's historic Wooster Street, is famous for its Neapolitan-style pizza baked in a wood-fired oven. Opened in 2016, the pizzeria emphasizes high-quality ingredients, such as San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. The cozy interior has a casual vibe, attracting both pizza aficionados and families alike. In addition to pizza, they offer a selection of Italian wines and house-made desserts, including tiramisu.
What the videos show
The video showcases two pizzas on a wooden table. The first pizza is topped with ham, sausage, and basil, while the second pizza features eggplant, zucchini, and red pepper. A hand enters the frame to sprinkle red pepper flakes over the second pizza.
138 Wooster St
@clinkdrinkeat.ct
Michelina’s Apizza & Ristorante
View Venue
$CozyWelcomingAuthenticHomemade pastaChicken parmigianaNotable wine
About the venue
Michelina's in New Haven is renowned for its Italian dining experience, specializing in classic pasta dishes since its establishment in 1988. The restaurant features a cozy space adorned with warm lighting and rustic decor, making it ideal for family dinners or special occasions. Signature dishes include homemade fettuccine and chicken parmigiana, alongside a notable wine list that complements the meals. Locals appreciate Michelina's for its welcoming atmosphere and consistently high-quality food.
What the videos show
The video showcases a variety of pizzas on a metal tray, including buffalo chicken, sausage broccoli, margherita, and bacon ranch. The camera pans across the tray, highlighting each pizza individually.
858 State St
@kleoeatz
Gioia
View Venue
$$CasualLivelyChicWood-fired pizzaNeapolitan stylePesto Burrata
About the venue
Gioia, nestled at 150 Wooster St in New Haven, serves up authentic Neapolitan pizza in a casual yet chic atmosphere. Established in 2016, this pizzeria features a wood-fired oven imported from Italy, allowing for a perfect crust and flavor. The menu boasts classic pizzas such as Margherita and more inventive options like the pesto and burrata topping. Locals enjoy the inviting space complete with communal seating and a casual vibe making it a great place for sharing meals.
What the videos show
The video showcases the interior of Gioia Cafe & Bar in New Haven, CT, featuring patrons dining, a close-up of a cocktail, a slice of pizza, and the rooftop bar area.
150 Wooster St
@NajeaYasmeen_
Pepe Frank Pizzeria Napoletana
View Venue
CozyAuthenticInvitingWood-fired pizzaItalian ingredientsCasual dining
About the venue
Pepe Frank Pizzeria Napoletana, located on Poplar St in New Haven, Connecticut, is famous for its authentic Neapolitan pizza. The pizzeria, established in 2015, features a wood-fired oven that creates the perfect crust, using high-quality ingredients sourced from Italy. The menu offers classic pizzas, calzones, and a selection of Italian desserts. It attracts pizza enthusiasts from all over, providing a casual dining experience in a cozy setting.
What the videos show
The video showcases the exterior and entrance of 'The Original Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana,' a brick building with large windows and a red awning. The camera moves closer to the entrance, revealing open glass doors and a sign that reads 'OPEN.' It then transitions inside, showing the restaurant's interior with visible tables.
232 Poplar St
@i.need.to.eat
@i.need.to.eat
Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant
View Venue
$CasualWelcomingFamily-friendlyNew York-styleLate-night hoursExtensive menu
About the venue
Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant, located on York Street in New Haven, Connecticut, is well-known for its large New York-style pizza slices and extensive menu including pasta and subs. The casual eatery has a welcoming atmosphere, ideal for students and families seeking a quick meal. Famous for its late-night hours, many patrons stop by after events or shows. It's a staple in the local dining scene, particularly for the pizza lovers.
What the videos show
The video showcases Yorkside Pizza and Restaurant, highlighting its exterior sign, menu, interior decor, and various pizza slices.
288 York St
@adventureswithchass
Rebar Bar And Pizza
View Venue
$LivelyCasualCommunity-focusedInventive pizzasTheme nightsCraft beers
About the venue
Rebar Bar And Pizza in West Haven focuses on casual dining with a twist, offering a menu of inventive pizzas and cocktails in a lively environment. The bar features a mix of classic and gourmet pizzas, alongside local craft beers. It is well-known for its fun theme nights and community events, drawing in a crowd of locals and visitors looking for a relaxed evening out. The space includes indoor and outdoor seating options for maximum comfort.
What the videos show
The video begins with a black screen and then transitions to a close-up of a pepperoni pizza rotating slowly. The pizza is covered in melted cheese and pepperoni slices, with a slightly charred crust. The camera captures the entire surface of the pizza as it rotates, highlighting its texture and ingredients.
250 Captain Thomas Blvd
@kleoeatz
Sherkaan Indian Street Food
View Venue
$$CasualVibrantTrendySamosasChaatCurry bowls
About the venue
Sherkaan Indian Street Food, located on Broadway in New Haven, offers an authentic taste of Indian street food staples since its opening in 2016. The menu features an array of dishes such as samosas, chaat, and curry bowls, capturing the essence of Indian cuisine. With a laid-back atmosphere, it appeals to students and locals who appreciate flavorful food at affordable prices. Known for their vibrant presentation and bold spices, Sherkaan has quickly become a favorite spot for Indian food lovers in the area.
What the videos show
The video showcases a close-up of two pieces of flatbread in a cardboard container, followed by a pan to reveal a box of noodles garnished with herbs, alongside two small cups of sauce. The camera captures all the items neatly arranged on a table.
65 Broadway
@what2nom