Best Pizza Restaurants in Tallahassee

Real videos of Pizza Restaurants in Tallahassee — 12 places, filmed by creators on the ground.

Ranked venues

Madison Social
View Venue
$$LivelySocialCommunity-focusedSouthern pubCraft beerLive music
About the venue
Madison Social in Tallahassee has been a neighborhood favorite since its opening in 2015, with a locally inspired menu featuring Southern pub grub. The lively atmosphere is often enhanced by community events and live music. Signature dishes include their ‘Madison’ burger and fried green tomatoes, while the bar boasts a solid selection of craft beers and cocktails. The combination of great food and social atmosphere makes it a popular spot for gatherings.
What the videos show
The video showcases a rectangular pizza topped with spinach, cheese, and red sauce, placed on a black tray on a wooden table. A hand enters the frame and lifts one corner of the pizza with a spatula before gently placing it back down.
705 S Woodward Ave
@soflofoodcoma
Brooklyn Pizza
View Venue
$CasualHomeyFunNew York-styleSpecialty piesPasta options
About the venue
Brooklyn Pizza, located on W Pensacola St in Tallahassee, is a well-known pizzeria that has been serving New York-style pizza since 1999. The restaurant is characterized by its large slices, foldable crusts, and variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni to unique specialty pies. Inside, the decor is casual, featuring memorabilia from Brooklyn, creating a fun and relaxed dining atmosphere. Guests can also enjoy a selection of pasta dishes and salads, making it more than just a pizza place.
What the videos show
The video shows a cheese pizza in a cardboard box. The camera remains still throughout the clip.
2035 W Pensacola St
@toric248
@toric248
Momo's Pizza
View Venue
$$CasualLate-nightCommunityLate-night slicesClassic pizzaAffordable
About the venue
Momo's Pizza on West Tennessee Street in Tallahassee offers a straightforward pizza menu featuring classic and specialty pizzas baked to order. The restaurant is recognized for its late-night hours, serving slices until the early morning. The casual atmosphere and inexpensive prices attract students and locals alike, creating a vibrant community spot. Regular promotions and combo deals encourage repeat visits from patrons looking for value.
What the videos show
The video shows a close-up of a large pepperoni pizza with various toppings such as tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives, and cheese. The camera remains static, focusing on the pizza, and a person's legs wearing blue shorts and white socks can be seen at the bottom of the frame.
1416 W Tennessee St
@toric248
@toric248
Bare Naked Kitchen
View Venue
$$HealthyBrightCasualFresh saladsGrain bowlsSustainable eating
About the venue
Bare Naked Kitchen, located on W Tennessee St in Tallahassee, focuses on fresh, healthy dining with a menu that showcases local produce. This casual eatery offers a variety of salads and grain bowls, emphasizing sustainability in its food sourcing. The bright decor and welcoming environment attract health-conscious diners and those looking for lighter meal options. Established recently, it has gained a reputation for quality and freshness.
What the videos show
The video showcases a rectangular pizza with toppings like pepperoni, red sauce, cheese, and basil leaves on a black slate plate. The camera slowly zooms out, revealing more of the table and surroundings.
609 W Tennessee St
@soflofoodcoma
@soflofoodcoma
Domino's Pizza
View Venue
$CasualFastConvenientPizza chainFast deliveryTakeout options
About the venue
Domino's Pizza, located at 3507 N Monroe St Ste C in Tallahassee, FL, is a branch of the well-known pizza chain offering a variety of pizzas, sides, and desserts. Established in the early 2000s, this location emphasizes fast delivery and convenient takeout options for busy customers. Signature menu items include the hand-tossed pizza and cheesy bread. The casual atmosphere is perfect for picking up dinner on-the-go or enjoying a quick meal.
What the videos show
The video shows a close-up of a slice of cheese pizza being held by a hand. The camera remains static throughout the clip, and there is a brief audio comment that seems disconnected from the visual content.
3507 N Monroe St Ste C
@toric248
World of Beer
View Venue
LivelyCasualBeer-focusedExtensive beerUpscale pubTrivia nights
About the venue
World of Beer on Lafayette Street in Tallahassee is both a restaurant and taproom featuring thousands of beers from around the world. Since 2014, it has attracted beer enthusiasts with its extensive selection, complemented by a menu of upscale pub fare. Guests can explore beer flights and attend weekly trivia nights, making it a lively venue for social gatherings. Outdoor seating adds to the appeal for those looking to enjoy the Florida weather.
What the videos show
The video focuses on a visually appealing rectangular pizza slice placed on a wooden board. The pizza features various toppings including arugula leaves, melted cheese, tomato sauce, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze. The crust is golden brown with slight charring at the edges. The camera remains still, capturing the details of the pizza.
830 E Lafayette St
@toric248
Momos Pizza
View Venue
CasualFriendlyAffordableCustom pizzaQuality ingredientsPizza specials
About the venue
Momos Pizza in Tallahassee is known for its classic pizzas and friendly service. Offering both delivery and dine-in options, this pizzeria focuses on quality ingredients and customizable toppings. Locals appreciate its casual atmosphere and the ability to create their own pizza masterpieces. Special deals like ‘pizza of the day’ make it an affordable option for families and students alike.
What the videos show
The video shows a close-up of a single slice of cheese pizza on a paper plate. The camera remains static throughout the clip.
424 El Destinado Dr
@toric248
@toric248
Brick House Restaurant & Bar
View Venue
$CasualFamily-friendlyWelcomingNew York-styleFresh ingredientsDine-in options
About the venue
Brick Haus Pizza in Tallahassee is known for its New York-style pizza made fresh daily with high-quality ingredients. Established in 2013, the pizzeria features a cozy dine-in area and takeout options for busy customers. Signature pizzas, including the Brick Haus Special, are popular among regulars, along with various salads and subs. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff contribute to a strong sense of community, making it a preferred pizza destination.
What the videos show
The video shows a cheese pizza in a cardboard box on a granite countertop. The camera remains static throughout the clip, capturing the melted cheese and herbs on the pizza, as well as the golden brown crust with some charred edges.
402 W College Ave
@toric248
Gaines Street Pies
View Venue
$Laid-backLocalCasualCreative pizzasSeasonal ingredientsVegan options
About the venue
Gaines Street Pies serves up a variety of delicious pizzas in Tallahassee, known for its creative toppings and made-from-scratch dough. Founded with a mission to celebrate local ingredients, they offer a rotating selection of seasonal pies alongside traditional favorites. The laid-back restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating, making it ideal for casual dining. Popular dishes include the 'Gaines Street Special' and vegan options for plant-based eaters.
What the videos show
The video shows a single slice of cheese pizza on a metal tray. The camera remains static throughout the clip.
603 W Gaines St
@toric248
@toric248
Marco's Pizza
View Venue
$CasualFamily-friendlyQuick-serviceCustom pizzasFresh ingredientsGluten-free options
About the venue
Marco's Pizza at 209 N Magnolia Dr in Tallahassee specializes in custom pizzas made with fresh ingredients and a variety of crust styles. The friendly atmosphere and quick service make it a popular choice for families and groups. Customers can create their own pizzas or choose from the menu's specialty options, including gluten-free dough. The location often caters to local events with large orders and delivery services.
What the videos show
The video shows two slices of cheese pizza on a white plate held by a person wearing a red long-sleeved shirt. The background features a gray tiled floor and a white wall.
209 N Magnolia Dr
@toric248
Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen
View Venue
$$CozyFamily-friendlyRusticHomemade pastaFamily recipesComforting meals
About the venue
Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen, located in Bellwood Estates, Florida, specializes in authentic Italian cuisine with a menu that boasts homemade pasta and traditional sauces. Opened in 2020, the restaurant features a rustic yet modern interior that seats about 50 people. Signature dishes include lasagna and fettuccine Alfredo, made from scratch using family recipes. The eatery attracts locals and families looking for a comforting meal in a welcoming setting.
What the videos show
The video showcases a close-up view of a freshly baked pizza with melted cheese, tomato sauce, and basil leaves. The camera remains stationary throughout the clip.
3813 N Monroe St
@toric248
Suwannee Room
View Venue
StylishFlexibleCommunity-focusedEvent spaceCatering optionsSouthern dishes
About the venue
The Suwannee Room, located at 143 Honors Way in Tallahassee, FL, is a cozy event space and restaurant known for hosting local gatherings and private events. Opened in 2021, it features flexible seating and modern decor, making it suitable for various occasions. The menu includes Southern-inspired dishes and has options for catering events. It's a popular venue for those looking to celebrate within a comfortable and stylish environment.
What the videos show
The video shows a slice of pizza on a white surface, with the camera remaining still throughout the short duration. The audio includes a brief 'Thank you.'
143 Honors Way
@toric248
@toric248