Best Italian Restaurants in Nantucket

Ranked venues

1. Oran Mor

   View Venue

   $$$•Cozy•Nautical•Relaxed•Lobster Bisque•Grilled Swordfish•Waterfront views

   About the venue

   Oran Mor, located on South Beach Street in Nantucket, features fresh, locally sourced seafood and seasonal produce in a cozy 150-seat dining space. The restaurant, opened in 2015, is well-known for its Lobster Bisque and Grilled Swordfish, offering a taste of New England cuisine. Its nautical-themed interior and waterfront views create a relaxing setting, drawing both locals and tourists seeking quality dining experiences. Local artwork and nautical décor contribute to the intimate atmosphere.

   What the videos show

   The video showcases a series of gourmet dishes, including beetroot risotto, crackers with cream cheese and red sauce, Brussels sprouts with mushrooms and pomegranate seeds, pasta with lobster meat, rigatoni with tomato-based sauce and minced beef, and steak with roasted potatoes and green beans, each presented on a white plate with artistic plating techniques.

   2 S Beach St

   

2. Black-Eyed Susan's

   View Venue

   $•Charming•Cozy•Local•Local seafood•Patio seating•Farm-to-table

   About the venue

   Black-Eyed Susan's in Nantucket specializes in a seasonal menu with an emphasis on local seafood and fresh, island-sourced ingredients. This intimate eatery is situated on India Street and is celebrated for its warm, inviting interior and outdoor patio. Guests frequently rave about signature dishes like the lobster roll and clam chowder. The restaurant also partners with nearby farms to offer seasonal produce, adding a unique farm-to-table experience.

   What the videos show

   The video showcases various dishes being served at a restaurant, including fish with potatoes, spaghetti, bread with butter, and fried cheese balls with pickles. The camera pans across the table, highlighting the food and the kitchen staff working in the background.

   10 India St

   

   @rosiera.415