Best Pizza Restaurants in Montauk

Ranked venues

1. Harvest on Fort Pond

   View Venue

   $$$•Rustic•Coastal•Social•Outdoor deck•Farm-to-table•Seasonal menu

   About the venue

   Harvest on Fort Pond, nestled in Montauk, NY, offers a farm-to-table dining experience and has been serving the community since 2013. Situated just off Fort Pond, the restaurant features a spacious outdoor deck perfect for enjoying the scenery while dining on locally sourced ingredients. The menu focuses on seasonal dishes, with drawn-out favorites like the grilled octopus and homemade pasta. The ambiance reflects Montauk's coastal vibe, attracting both locals and summer visitors.

   What the videos show

   The video showcases a close-up view of a pizza topped with tomatoes and cheese, followed by a plate of sliced tomatoes with mozzarella and balsamic glaze, and finally a Caesar salad. The camera pans across these dishes, highlighting their details.

   11 S Emery St

   

   @gimmeabiteee

2. Best Pizza & Dive Bar

   View Venue

   $$•Laid-back•Eclectic•Cozy•White clam•Local beers•Casual atmosphere

   About the venue

   Best Pizza & Dive Bar is situated on Montauk Hwy in Napeague, offering an eclectic menu that pairs pizza with a casual bar atmosphere. This laid-back spot has become a favorite among locals and beach-goers since it opened. The menu features classic pizzas alongside creative options like the White Clam Pizza available for dine-in or takeout. The bar serves local beers and unique cocktails, perfect for winding down after a day at the beach.

   What the videos show

   The video showcases various food items, including garlic knots, chicken wings, and two different types of pizza. The camera pans across these items, highlighting their arrangement and details.

   2095 Montauk Hwy

   

   @gimmeabiteee